Scientology
Cult Friction
After an embarrassing string of high-profile defection and leaked videos, Scientology is under attack from a faceless cabal of online activists. Has America's most controversial religion finally met its match?
PAGE 1 / 4
Masked hackers have declared war on Scientology. Could the celebrity-friendly religion be in its final days? (Photo: Sam Comen)
Clearwater is prepared for its enemies. It's a warm, if overcast, Saturday in February, but all the storefronts lining the sidewalks of this sleepy town on the Gulf Coast of Florida are shuttered. The streets are mostly barren, and at the sight of strangers, the few passersby quicken their pace and avert their eyes. Outwardly, Clearwater has all the hallmarks of an unexceptional beach community—there's a Starbucks on the corner, and new construction projects dot the shoreline. But today the cranes are still and the scaffolding is empty. No one is lining up for lattes. Everyone, it seems, has disappeared.
"There's one!" says Patricia Greenway, my guide, as we drive past a dark-haired woman in black slacks and a short-sleeve white shirt. When she notices us eyeballing her through the car window, she raises her hand like a scandalized starlet confronting the paparazzi. "See—she's hiding her face," Greenway says quietly, sounding like the host of an Animal Planet safari special. "They feel that if they're exposed to entheta, they'll lose their bridge."
Their "bridge" is the "Bridge to Total Freedom," the path to enlightenment, levitation, time travel, and all-around invincibility peddled by L. Ron Hubbard under the name Scientology. "Entheta" is us. The enemy.
A clean-cut young man points a video camera our way, slowly pivoting to keep us in the frame. The Scientologists are monitoring their enemies. And they are expecting more to comeEver since Hubbard, the portly flame-haired naval enthusiast, accomplished liar, pulp fiction writer, and unlikely cult leader, came ashore here in 1975 after leading his flock on an eight-year sea voyage throughout Europe and the Mediterranean, Clearwater has been known as the "spiritual mecca" of Scientology. Members call it Flag Land Base. Beginning with its purchase of the Fort Harrison Hotel that year, the Church has methodically acquired most of downtown Clearwater, save for the library and the courthouse, amassing nearly 1.7 million square feet of office and residential space and turning the city center into a virtual Scientology campus. More than 1,200 Church staff members, and somewhere between 5,000 and 12,000 Scientologists—including Kirstie Alley (who purchased her home from Lisa Marie Presley)—live and work here. Which is exceedingly creepy, especially when they're nowhere to be found. Even so, I am skeptical when Greenway and her associate, Peter Alexander, both outspoken critics of Scientology, hesitate to get out of the car and walk around. What could really happen to us? The sidewalk is still ostensibly public property.
Alexander, a soft-spoken former vice president of Universal Studios who now lives near Clearwater, attained the Church's second-highest level of spiritual awakening, OT VII, or Operating Thetan level seven, before he defected in 1997. At one point, Alexander says, he was so consumed with Scientology that he carried around a Church-issued beeper that alerted him whenever his minders decided he required counseling. Greenway, a no-nonsense blonde with a pack-a-day voice and an easy laugh, was never a Scientologist. Alexander hired her in the mid-'90s at his architectural design firm, which at the time was run using Hubbard's principles; she resisted the workplace pressure to join Scientology and eventually convinced Alexander to leave the Church. They both joined the board of the Lisa McPherson Trust—a now-defunct anti-Scientology organization that battled the Church in Clearwater for years—and made a feature-length film called The Profit about a megalomaniacal leader named L. Conrad Powers who founds the Church of Scientific Spiritualism.
Greenway and Alexander have steered clear of downtown Clearwater for several months and fear that if they're spotted in the area, the Church will unleash private investigators on them (as they claim it has in the past), and that a new wave of troubling phone calls and attempts to meddle with their business will commence. This strikes me as paranoid. Eventually, we park the car and get out. Alexander points to a Greek-columned stone building that once housed the town bank. It is now the headquarters of the Office of Special Affairs, the Church's public relations arm and current incarnation of the Guardian Office, which was the epicenter of the black-bag hijinks for which Scientology is famous—infiltrating the Department of Justice, hatching schemes (which were never fully realized) to blackmail critics, bugging IRS offices, and so forth. A discreetly posted security camera peeks out from atop the building. "They've got 110 cameras downtown," Alexander says. "Just wait."
Within minutes, a paunchy middle-age Latino man with a pencil-thin mustache, wearing khakis and a white golf shirt, emerges from the adjoining parking lot. He walks silently to a spot a few feet away from us, points a digital camera, and begins snapping our picture. I say hello. He says nothing. I ask him if he's a member of the Church. He stares, grim-faced, at the camera's LCD screen. Alexander and Greenway are casual; they've been through this before.
As we continue down the sidewalk, a bus with tinted windows passes by. Greenway explains that it's a Scientology bus. The Church leaders don't trust the staff to own cars, she says, and they don't want them walking around with entheta, either.
Greenway points across the street. The venetian blinds in the storefront opposite have been opened to reveal an office with at least half a dozen people inside. One of them, a clean-cut young man, is standing by the window, pointing a video camera, and slowly pivoting to keep us in the frame as we make our way down Cleveland Street.
The Scientologists are monitoring their enemies. And they are expecting more to come.
HOTEL CALIFORNIA Scientology's Celebrity Centre in Los Angeles. One of the sites of Anonymous' February 10, 2008, protests (Photo: Getty Images)
Then came the video. You've probably seen it by now—leaked footage of Tom Cruise accepting the Church's Freedom Medal of Valor award at a 2004 gathering of the International Association of Scientologists. Slickly produced, with the theme from Mission: Impossible pumping along in the background, the clip features a manic Cruise exhorting his co-religionists to commit themselves to the cause. "Being a Scientologist, when you drive past an accident, it's not like anyone else," he says. "As you drive past, you know you have to do something about it. Because you're the only one who can help."
The Tom Cruise video first appeared on YouTube on January 14, the day before Morton's biography went on sale. (According to one longtime critic of Scientology who is in contact with other anti-cult activists, the leak was purposefully timed to coincide with the book's release.) It was up for one day before the Church forced YouTube to take it down, citing copyright infringement. The clumsy attempt at censorship angered many on the Web, including the Manhattan media site Gawker, which obtained its own copy and continues to host the video despite the threat of a lawsuit. At press time, the footage had been viewed more than 2.7 million times.
Then came Anonymous. On January 21, a video titled "Message to Scientology" appeared on YouTube. A brilliant work of agitprop, the video (embedded below) features a monotone, computer-generated voice speaking in staccato against a mesmerizing backdrop of gathering clouds. The message, which bears quoting at length, is ominous:
"Hello, Scientology. We are Anonymous. Over the years, we have been watching you. Your campaigns of misinformation, suppression of dissent, your litigious nature: All of these things have caught our eye. With the leakage of your latest propaganda video into mainstream circulation, the extent of your malign influence over those who have come to trust you has been made clear to us. Anonymous has therefore decided that your organization should be destroyed. ... We are Anonymous. We are legion. We do not forgive. We do not forget. Expect us."
Within hours of the video's posting, all hell broke loose. Almost immediately, the Church's main website, scientology.org, went down under a distributed denial of service attack, a classic hacker technique that overwhelms a target's website with phantom user traffic until it crashes. Scientology offices worldwide were flooded with prank phone calls and so-called black faxes—pages upon pages of blank black pages—tying up their phone lines and emptying ink cartridges. Dozens of proprietary Church documents—videos, lectures, and course materials worth hundreds of thousands of dollars in Scientology's pay-to-pray scheme—began showing up on YouTube, BitTorrent, and countless websites.
Anonymous is the catchall term for an amorphous group of online activists-slash-hackers-slash-pranksters-slash-dadaists organized loosely around two online message boards, 4chan.org and 711chan.org. Anons, as they call themselves, are steeped in the anarchic and exceptionally juvenile culture of the Internet, and function as something like online yippies. The lolcats meme, for example—a series of inexplicably funny pictures of cats with comically misspelled captions like, "I can has cheezburger?"—first emerged on the 4chan boards, and its members have claimed responsibility for a long list of feats, including taking down white nationalist websites and stealing the passwords to 72,000 MySpace pages.
Anonymous managed to disrupt the Scientology website for three days. And in a show of force—and a surprising departure from its previous, Internet-focused projects—it also dispatched legions of real live protesters to Scientology facilities around the world for coordinated pickets.
Add to that the recent defections of several prominent Church members, including David Miscavige's own niece, Jenna Miscavige Hill—who is openly attacking her uncle and the Church—and Mike Rinder, the Church's former chief spokesman and public face, and you can see why the folks in Clearwater are wary of outsiders.
"It's looking like the perfect storm," says Dave Touretzky, a research professor of computer science at Carnegie Mellon University and a longtime critic of the Church. "I just can't believe what's happened over the last six months. It's all falling apart for Scientology now. We're looking at the end times for them."
PAGE 2 / 4
FREEDOM FIGHTERS Anonymous' tagline: "Because none of us is as cruel as all of us" (Photo: Sam Comen)
Scientology, of course, has always thrived when it's under attack. Hubbard was keen to make sure that its enemies, whether real or imagined, loomed large in the lives of his adherents. He railed against "the forces of evil [who] have launched their lies and sought, by whatever twisted means, to check and destroy Scientology"—whether they be IRS agents, psychiatrists, or reporters, whom he dubbed "merchants of chaos." A pillar of the Church's theology is the existence of "suppressive persons," who must be avoided, or "handled," in the Church's euphemistic jargon. In 1967, Hubbard promulgated what he called the "fair game" policy, whereby anyone judged to be an antagonist "may be deprived of property or injured [and] tricked, sued or lied to, or
destroyed." (He later withdrew it, citing "bad PR.") Miscavige has chosen his own aggressive, protomilitant style, pumping up Scientology troops with talk of an "assault on planetary suppression" and the "global obliteration" of psychiatry, Scientology's bête noire.
Scientologists covertly infiltrated one critic's life, befriended her, and, an FBI agent later told her, framed her by using stationery with her fingerprints on it to send bomb threats to the ChurchIn keeping with Hubbard's fair game dictate, every time Scientology has been attacked, it has quickly struck back, which is what makes the current barrage against the Church so remarkable. Not long ago, anyone brave enough to publicly criticize the organization suffered dearly. Paulette Cooper, an investigative journalist whose 1971 exposé, The Scandal of Scientology, was the first mainstream book to criticize the Church, found herself subjected to what she described as a 15-year campaign of harassment. Scientologists covertly infiltrated her life, befriended her, and, an FBI agent later told her, framed her by using stationery with her fingerprints on it to send bomb threats to the Church. Branded a lunatic, she became suicidal, lost her boyfriend, and was down to 83 pounds when a 1977 FBI raid on Scientology offices in L.A. and Washington, D.C., turned up documents indicating she had been the target of "Operation Freakout"—a coordinated campaign to get her "incarcerated in a mental institution or jail, or at least to hit her so hard that she drops her attacks."
Fourteen years later, after writer Richard Behar wrote a blistering cover story for Time headlined "The Thriving Cult of Greed and Power," the Church unsuccessfully sued the magazine for $416 million and sicced six private investigators on Behar himself, obtaining his phone records and credit reports, and digging into his personal life. Likewise, former Scientologists who have spoken out have found themselves cut off from their families and worse. Alexander says his clients have received calls from people claiming that he ripped them off. He believes the calls were placed by Church members.
As recently as February, according to Miscavige's estranged niece, a reporter for a British tabloid received a vaguely threatening phone call after interviewing her. The reporter had contacted the Church's press office seeking a response to Hill's claims that the religion tears families apart. Shortly thereafter, he received a call from a stranger asking if his mother knew that he was working on a story about Hill. The caller then recited the writer's mother's home address. Soon after, the story was killed.
The journalist, a freelancer whom Radar has agreed not to name, says the story never ran because it lacked a celebrity angle. But he acknowledges that he received a troubling call and that his status as a self-employed reporter without the backing of a newspaper made it difficult to ignore. "If it weren't little old me, I wouldn't blink," he says. "But I have blinked, and there's not much that can be done about it."
Few expect the hackers behind Anonymous to blink. In fact, rarely has an opponent of Scientology so gleefully played into the Church's paranoia and xenophobia.
"It's not against their people or religion," says one Anonymous member who, predictably, declined to offer his identity. "We respect the right for them to believe what they want. We oppose their lawsuits and their bully tactics. Every religion goes through its stages of infancy. The Catholics had the Crusades, but for the first time in history, the common people have enough power to stop Scientology before it gets to that."
Given Anonymous' decentralized nature, it's difficult to gauge the individual motives of its members. Literally anyone with a computer can "join." And it's not just hacker nihilists: doctors, lawyers, and professors are involved, they claim. "Anonymous," says a member who calls herself Sarah, "is a collective group of individuals with no leader, who do anything they can and want."
A few days after Anonymous' "Message to Scientology" appeared on YouTube, powder-filled envelopes arrived at 19 Los Angeles–area Scientology facilities. The powder was harmless, but the FBI was called in to investigate. Anons interviewed by Radar disavowed the mailings and suggested the envelopes were sent by Scientologists themselves to discredit Anonymous—a tactic the Church had used against Paulette Cooper—and claimed that, as a free-form public movement, members have no control over every action taken in their name. Another wayward attack, according to "Sarah," involved someone faxing hundreds of pages with only the word "nigger" printed on them over and over again, to a number mistakenly believed to be affiliated with the Church. She regrets that, but says she's helped "successfully stop a lot of other people who had really stupid plans." The Church has denounced Anonymous as a "cyber-terrorist group" committing "hate crimes" and accused them of "bomb threats, death threats, and threats to burn down Church buildings."
"The Church can confirm that appropriate law enforcement authorities are investigating the criminal acts of Anonymous," Scientology spokeswoman Karin Pouw wrote in a 10-page response to Radar's questions. "[Anonymous] will not disrupt the Church's normal activities of serving its parishioners and the community." (Click here to read the church's entire response in PDF form.)
In a sign that they were more than just a passing Internet fad, Anonymous soon graduated from pulling pranks just for the "lulz"—anonyspeak for shits and giggles—to real-life, up close and personal activism. February 10 is the birthday of Lisa McPherson, the 36-year-old Scientologist who died from dehydration in Clearwater in 1995 while in the Church's care. She was allegedly in the midst of a psychotic breakdown, and the Church was reluctant to hospitalize her for fear that she would be treated by a psychiatrist. McPherson's death sparked a round of back-and-forth litigation and galvanized anti-Scientology groups. On what would have been her 49th birthday, Anonymous scheduled protests in front of Scientology facilities in 100 cities worldwide. They planned to wear V for Vendetta Guy Fawkes masks, hand out leaflets, and carry signs. According to Anonymous, 6,000 people showed up around the world. My first visit to Clearwater's eerily deserted downtown was on February 9, the day before the planned protest.
MAGIC KINGDOM Saint Hill Manor in East Grinstead, the home of L. Ron Hubbard (Photo: Getty Images)
The Church has set its sights on African Americans, opening up a center in Harlem in 2003 and making a strong play for Hollywood supercouple Will Smith and Jada Pinkett Smith"Robert Vaughn Young once said the Internet is going to be Scientology's Waterloo," says frequent Scientology critic and journalist Mark Ebner, referring to a high-level defector. "And he was right."
Scientology's outlandish creation myth is a closely held secret within the organization—learning about it prior to reaching OT III is said to cause mental retardation or, by some accounts, death. But for potential recruits, it is a simple matter of Googling—or watching South Park—to learn that Hubbard believed an interstellar overlord named Xenu killed billions of beings in an attempt to thwart galactic overpopulation 75 million years ago. Their souls, Hubbard taught, infest Earth-goers and can only be removed through a hybrid of counseling and interrogation known as auditing, using an E-meter, or crude lie detector.
Faced with an increasingly skeptical public here at home, former members say, the Church has begun to target its recruitment efforts at communities statistically less likely to have Web access. In particular, it has stepped up its efforts in Central America, where, according to remarks made by Mike Rinder at a Scientology gathering in 2004, the first lady of Honduras is a convert. Critics point out that much of the anti-Scientology material available online has yet to be translated into Spanish, making Spanish-speakers an easier sell. The Church has also set its sights on African Americans, opening up a center in Harlem in 2003 and making a strong play for Hollywood supercouple
Even as Scientology comes under assault from outside forces, it is also, say former members, bleeding from within. "I see more and more people leaving and willing to speak," says Tory Christman, who worked in the Office of Special Affairs for 20 years and says she spent more than $200,000 on Scientology courses before dropping out in 2000. Christman left—or "blew," in Scientology parlance—because she has epilepsy and wasn't permitted to take medication for it; psychiatric and neurological drugs are a serious no-no. But after two decades of working her way up the Bridge, she was forced to confront the fact that even L. Ron Hubbard could not cure epilepsy.
"At the top ranks, there's a very high blow rate," says Beatty. "They can't take it anymore."
Indeed, Scientology faces an inherent conundrum: Adherents are ushered up the Bridge with specific promises that they will be able to leave their bodies at will, stop time, read minds, and never succumb to illness. As long as there's another level to rise to, former Scientologists say, it's easy enough to convince yourself that your magical powers are just around the corner (even if they were supposed to have already materialized). "I got in it because I thought the out-of-body experience was real," says Beatty. "And after 20 years, I found out, it's not. But by the time you've gotten there, you've dumped a couple hundred thousand dollars, or like me, 20 years of your life into it. You don't want to give up. It's a group fantasy."
To keep that fantasy, and the attendant revenue stream, going, the Church has had to come up with new ways to dangle advancements beyond OT VIII—ostensibly the highest level you can reach, according to Hubbard—without seeming too craven. In 1995, Miscavige announced what he called "the golden age of tech," which was essentially a claim that Scientology's auditors had been doing everything all wrong. "We just discovered a treasure trove of L. Ron Hubbard," Miscavige said, meaning that everyone needed to do their courses over. And pay for them, naturally.
But the coup de grâce of Scientology's campaign to keep its members motivated and their wallets open is a massive 380,000-square-foot Mediterranean Revival structure, occupying a whole block in Clearwater across from the Fort Harrison Hotel, known as the Super Power Building. Though the Church broke ground on the building a decade ago, and almost everything has been flawlessly in place on the exterior since 2004, it is still not completed. According to the Church's website, the Super Power Building will contain 889 rooms on six floors, a dining room that can serve 1,400 people, facilities for 1,200 staffers and 1,600 "parishioners," five miles of carpet, and 180 miles of electrical wiring. The Church has announced and ignored innumerable completion dates; it now says it expects the building to open in mid-2008.
PAGE 3 / 4
Some former Scientologists attribute the delay—for which the Church has been receiving daily fines of $250 from the city—to the Church's fund-raising prowess. Donna Shannon, a former member who donated a total of $50,000 toward the construction of the facility, says that as long as the Church can appeal to members for donations, ostensibly to help finance the building, it will remain incomplete.
Scientology's new building will include an antigravity simulator; a human-size gyroscope; oversize furniture to help determine spacial relationships; and a circular track to run around, over and over againBut others say that the Church is still perfecting the secret training regimen the structure was intended to house—the super power rundown, a course that will give Scientologists, well, superpowers. The building's amenities will include an antigravity simulator; a human-size gyroscope to teach students how to orient their bodies; television screens that move around, rapidly flashing images to drill members on how to perceive subliminal images; a facility for producing a variety of odors to train the olfactory sense; oversize furniture to help determine spacial relationships; and a circular track to run around, over and over again. The rundown is a new course that even OT VIII's will want to pay for.
Matt Feshbach, a billionaire hedge fund manager and devoted Scientologist, is one of the lucky few who has experienced a pilot program of the super power rundown. Apparently, it works. "I'm not dependent on my physical body to perceive things," he told the St. Petersburg Times in 2006, adding that he had already saved the life of a young boy with his new abilities by stopping him from running into the street.
One Scientologist who has apparently forsaken his superpowers is Mike Rinder, formerly head of the Office of Special Affairs and chief spokesman for Scientology. In what many ex-members describe as a significant black eye for the Church, Rinder blew last summer and now lives in Williamsburg, Virginia. Rinder was one of the most powerful men in the organization; it was his Australian baritone that proclaimed on ABC's 20/20 in 1998: "Every few thousand years a man comes along who is so extraordinary he changes the course of history, and L. Ron Hubbard is one of those men."
"Rinder leaving Scientology is like Goebbels leaving the Nazis," says Beatty, who speculates that Rinder couldn't put up with Miscavige any longer. Miscavige is notorious, former Scientologists say, for mistreating and screaming at underlings.
(Church spokeswoman Karin Pouw "categorically denies" any allegation that Miscavige has mistreated anyone: "Mr. Miscavige is a beloved and respected leader. Your question is offensive in the extreme." As for Rinder's current status in the Church, she says, "Religious membership is personal." Efforts to reach Rinder through another ex-Scientologist who has been in contact with him were unsuccessful.)
Miscavige, for his part, is having trouble keeping his own family in the Church, let alone his henchmen. In 2000, his brother Ron and Ron's wife, Bitty, left Gold Base—a formerly top-secret facility roughly 90 miles east of Los Angeles that serves as the Church's international headquarters—for Virginia. Both Miscavige brothers were raised in the Church by their father, a Polish-born musician who joined Scientology while living in Philadelphia. (It was David, however, who caught Hubbard's eye and served as his assistant from the age of 14.)
Ron Miscavige has remained silent since his defection. He did not return Radar's phone calls or e-mails. But his daughter, Jenna Miscavige Hill—David's niece—caused an uproar in February by writing an open letter to Pouw denouncing the Church's policy of "disconnection," in which followers are forced to forgo contact with anyone declared a suppressive person, even family members. Pouw had previously issued a statement in response to Morton's book, claiming that disconnection is "the opposite of what the Church believes and practices."
That, Hill says, is not true. "If they're so arrogant that they can completely lie when people know the truth, they're not going to change," she says. "I felt like I had to say something."
Hill says the Church tried to keep her from talking to her parents from 2000, when they left the Church (she was 16 at the time), until 2005, when she followed suit. Moreover, she describes a harrowing childhood as a third-generation Scientologist, in which, even as a small child, her life was heavily regimented and she was required to do manual labor.
From the age of six, Hill lived at Castile Canyon Ranch, a private Scientology-run boarding school near Hemet, California, about 20 miles from Gold Base, where her parents lived and worked as Scientology staff. (Scientology is divided into "staff" and "public" members; many of the staff are under total control of the Scientology hierarchy and receive courses for free or at a discount, while public members like Greta Van Susteren and Tom Cruise are free to do as they please and pay for courses.)
"I saw my parents once a week," Hill says. Along with 80 other children of staff at Gold Base, she says, she woke up every morning at 6:30, put on a uniform, and cleaned her room until inspection at 7 a.m. Then she worked handing out vitamins to other kids. After that, she says, "We'd do rock hauling and demolition, dig trenches, plant trees." When the grueling physical chores were done, she would study academics and Scientology materials until 9:30 p.m. "It's kind of weird when you're six or seven years old to have to study until 9:30 at night," she says. "We had units, we had to call people Sir, we did close-order drilling. It was run like a military organization."
Hill has fond memories of her uncle David from her time at Gold Base. Her family often spent Christmas holidays with Miscavige, she says, and he would take her to movies and even once to a hockey game. Things changed when, at age 12, she was drafted into the Sea Org, an elite cadre of Scientology staff. Hill recalls, "I went to Clearwater to visit some friends, and they said, 'Here's your uniform. You're in the Sea Org.' After that, it wasn't the same. He wasn't my uncle anymore. He was Sir. He's like God there."
In Clearwater, Sea Org recruits sign a contract promising one billion years of service to the organization; in the event of death, inductees are allowed 20 years to "grow the body" after they are reincarnated, at which point they are expected to report for duty. They are also required to fill out an exhaustive questionnaire bearing this quote from Hubbard: "You can't be shot for what you have done, you can only be shot for what you haven't told us." The Church asks whether applicants have ever been affiliated with the CIA or Mossad or have ever held a security clearance, and requires them to fill out a detailed sexual history, including "any perversions" and "who, what was done, and how often—be as complete as you can."
During her four years in Clearwater, Hill says she went to school once a week. She spent the rest of her time studying Scientology and performing administrative work. Her parents stayed back at Gold Base, and Hill says she saw her mother "once for about a half-hour" and her father "three times for at most a half-hour each time" over those four years.
Nicholai Allen, a classmate of Hill's at the ranch, corroborates her story. "I was seven when my mom took a job at Gold Base," he says. "She had no idea that she wouldn't be living with me when she got there—she wasn't given a choice. Almost immediately I was put to work cleaning bathrooms, harvesting vegetables, and building rock walls."
One day, when Hill was 16, the local head of the Religious Technology Center, the body in charge of enforcing Church doctrine, told her she needed a "sec check," or security check—a lengthy inquest using an E-meter. "I was interrogated eight hours a day for six weeks," she says. "I couldn't talk to my friends. I had to put on a grubby uniform, and when I wasn't being interrogated, I had to clean the bathroom. When I slept, there was always someone guarding the room." She was never told why.
Jenna Miscavige Hill, the estranged niece of David Miscavige, describes a harrowing childhood in which, even as a small child, her life was heavily regimented and she was required to do manual laborAfter six weeks, she was flown to L.A. When she arrived, she was told to go to the Office of Special Affairs' boardroom, where she found Mike Rinder and Marty Rathbun, Miscavige's second-in-command. "[Rinder] said, 'Your parents are leaving, and you're going with them.'" The sec check was standard operating procedure for anyone—even a 16-year-old—leaving the Church. "They wanted to know if I had any evil intentions toward my uncle," Hill says. "They wanted to find out if I was going to speak out."
To the contrary, Hill chose the Church over her family. "I was brainwashed, so I didn't want to go," Hill says. She convinced Rinder, Rathbun, and her parents to let her stay on in L.A. and remain on the staff of the Sea Org.
Hill never attended school again. During her time in the L.A. Sea Org, she says, all of her parents' letters to her were intercepted, and she was forced to read and answer questions about them in the presence of Rinder. She eventually married a fellow Scientologist named Dallas. In 2005, after a particularly aggressive auditing session in which she was questioned for hours because she criticized her superiors for attempting to take away her cell phone—Hill's only mode of contact with her parents—she announced that she wanted to leave the Church. "It was after a culmination of a lifetime of things," she says, that the cell phone issue finally flipped a switch in her head. Dallas, who was more indoctrinated, took some convincing, and the couple put off the decision for a few months. Hill later found out that during that time, Rinder and other people in the Office of Special Affairs were covertly interrogating Dallas. "They were secretly talking to my husband," she says. "Mike Rinder was telling Dallas bad things about my family, [encouraging him] to reevaluate, and telling him that he wouldn't be able to talk to his parents. Not to keep Dallas, but just to fuck with me."
Finally, after Dallas broke down and told Hill about the secret interrogations, the couple agreed to leave. "We went and stayed at a Travelodge," Hill says. "They showed up the next day with a U-Haul full of our stuff. The guy delivering it told Dallas, 'I'm going to do everything in my power to make sure your family disconnects from you.'"
"We had no money," she says. "No credit. I didn't have a driver's license. No nothing. I was 22. There are a ton of people like me."
Hill and her husband now live in San Diego. She declines to talk on the record about her current relationship with her parents, but says of her upbringing, "I wouldn't even let that happen to my dog."
"Jenna Miscavige speaking out is probably the most devastating thing to happen to them so far in terms of long-term damage," says Carnegie Mellon's Dave Touretzky. "To hear that [David Miscavige's] own niece left the Church and is accusing him of breaking up her family—that's huge."
Asked about Hill's account of her childhood, Pouw said: "The Church does not comment on how parents choose to educate and raise their children. Children were never forced to engage in manual labor." According to Pouw, "Facilities provided by the Church for the children of staff at [Gold Base] were nothing short of spectacular. In addition to a boarding school, facilities included swimming pools, basketball courts, football fields, baseball diamonds, and even horse stables. Citrus orchards and organic gardens, maintained by professionally trained gardeners, were also provided."
"Yeah, there was a stable," Hill says bitterly in response. "And we were the ones who built the horse corral. We were the ones who hauled the horse shit every week. I rode a horse one time in the six years I was there."
PAGE 4 / 4
THE WEBSITE SCIENTOLOGY DOESN'T WANT YOU TO SEE A protester in Toronto promotes xenu.net, one of the Web's most prominent anti-Scientology sites (Photo: Joe Howell)
On the morning of February 10, Lisa McPherson's birthday, Clearwater is desolate again. A broken car horn wails incessantly somewhere in the distance.
Anonymous begins gathering at about 11 a.m. The Church has hired nine off-duty police officers to provide security at the march; there's an air of a high-noon showdown in the offing. The assembled Anons are surprisingly diverse. One protester I spoke to gave his name as "Wesley Crusher," the youngest crew member in Star Trek: The Next Generation, but the crowd extends beyond the usual hacker suspects—there's a schoolteacher, college and high school students, even a few fraternity types. Many are dressed in suits; all have some sort of bandanna or mask covering their faces. By 1 p.m., the appointed time of the march, close to 200 people have collected at a staging area near the library. Someone pulls out a birthday cake for Lisa McPherson, and, in a surprisingly earnest moment for an Internet-based assault force, the crowd sings "Happy Birthday." Dave, the young, self-appointed leader of the group, urges restraint. "Let's not burn down any buildings," he says. "I've got to say that 'cause I know some of you all are pyros. Xenu is watching you, so be careful."
You may have thought you were reading about Katie Holmes' Armani dress in Us Weekly, but to David Miscavige, coverage of Cruise's wedding "amounted to an intro lecture" to Hubbard's teachingsThe march turns out to be the largest protest against Scientology in the history of Clearwater. Old-hand anti-cult activists who come down to check it out are impressed. The signs read "Ron's gone but the con goes on" and "Honk if you hate Scientology." For the next two hours, a chorus of car horns continually blares.
"I think it's great to see people protesting," says one local woman who refuses to give her name. "I work for a company that's owned by Scientologists. I just got the job for money. I didn't know it would be creepy and weird."
Another local couple says they just came downtown for the afternoon, not to protest, and someone took a picture of their license plate as they parked. "We had no idea this was the epicenter of Scientology," the woman says. "Otherwise, we wouldn't have moved here."
The surveillance is in full effect as I make my way around downtown; young men in short-sleeve shirts, khakis, and sunglasses seem to emerge out of nowhere to snap your picture each time you walk past a Scientology building. They don't respond to questions or acknowledge your presence, they just stare at the camera's screen. I spot one woman walking down the street carrying an L. Ron Hubbard book and ask her what she makes of the crowd chanting "Cult! Cult! Cult!" "I don't have any thoughts whatsoever," she replies curtly.
The protest is peaceful, with no arrests or confrontations. According to Karin Pouw, 5,000 Scientologists were inside the Church buildings engaged in religious services without regard to the "terrorists" outside. As the picket line starts to dissolve, I make my way back to my car, down a deserted side street. I am the only one on the sidewalk. A white Japanese car drives past me; as I look over I see a blonde woman snap my picture from the passenger seat. I walk faster. Fumbling for my keys, I spot a brown car pulling out of the supermarket driveway, across from the lot where I've parked my car. The driver lifts up a digital camera, snaps a shot of me, and drives away.
According to Anonymous, the protests brought out a total of 6,000 protestors in more than 100 cities worldwide, including more than 500 each in London and Los Angeles. The group insists that the campaign will continue: On March 15, Hubbard's birthday, Anonymous is organizing mock birthday parties at Scientology centers worldwide. In April, it will launch Operation Reconnection to increase awareness of the disconnection policy. Anonymous member "Sarah" says the group is also organizing a letter-writing campaign designed to take aim at the Church's nonprofit religious classification. "We're sending letters to senators and congresspeople requesting that their tax-exempt status be looked at."
FACE OFF Armed with signs and megaphones, Anonymous protesters chant "Cult! Cult! Cult!" (Photo: Sam Comen)
And Scientology isn't taking Anonymous' attacks lying down: A representative told the St. Petersburg Times that the Church would work to identify the protesters that gathered in Clearwater on February 10, because "any of them could be a security risk." "Sarah" says that one of her cohorts received a text message from an unidentified number bearing the message: "If you know what's good for you, you'll stop lying about Scientology. This is your last warning." The main website used by Anonymous for planning events has been dogged by denial of service attacks for weeks. And in mid-February, a new video purporting to be from Anonymous appeared on YouTube. It threatened to blow up a Scientology building in Los Angeles. Suspicious it could be a fair game tactic, Anonymous members immediately informed the FBI that it didn't come from them. YouTube removed the video, along with the original computer-narrated manifesto. (The latter video was eventually restored; the Church denies any role in getting it taken down.)
Still, the genie is out of the bottle. As Bruce Hines, a former OT VII who left the Church, says, "With all this publicity, very few people would go home after work and say, 'Oh, honey, I just found out about Scientology and I'm going to take this course.' The response would be, 'What? Are you crazy?'"
Click here to view the official response from the Church of Scientology.
This article is from the April issue of Radar Magazine. For a risk-free issue, click here
Related: Scientology
Posted by: poink on March 18, 2008 12:57 PM
Thank you for the very factual and courageous article. I was a Scientology Sea Org Member for more than 20 years and worked at the International Base in Hemet. I can attest that the facts as you present them about the dark side of Scientology are accurate. And you've only just begun to uncover the truth about this group. The organization is corrupt and abusive. Rank-and-file Scientologists have no clue what is going on at corporate levels. Thanks to the courage of Jenna Miscavige, Anonymous, and many former members now speaking out, the truth will be known.
Posted by: orwell on March 18, 2008 1:01 PM
For more on Jenna Miscavige Hill and other former Scientology kids, go to www.exscientologykids.com
And don't forget Operation Reconnect on April 12th 2006, at your local Scientology Center everywhere in the world.
Posted by: suzette on March 18, 2008 1:56 PM
Most people still see Scientology as a kooky cult, so it's great that journalists such as yourself are getting the truth out there.
There's so much that the general public doesn't know about this organization. Critics frequently bring up "Operation Snow White," I guess as it's well documented, it happened in the US, etc. etc.
However there are other tales that are not disimilar. You have to understand that the "church" doesn't see itself as being subject to the rule of law. As Tom Cruise puts it "Why ask? we are the authorites."
Another gr8 story you might be interested in covering, was the church's plan to take over parts of parts of four countries, forming a new one that would have been called Bulgravia.
This was discovered when some of their planning documents were seized by police in Greece, (along with Top Secret Greek military documents!...this is a church????)
Anyway, great article,. thanks.
Posted by: MickyC on March 18, 2008 3:35 PM
Great job on this article!
Just got done reading the pdf of the official scientology response. Amazing. Talk about creating your own reality. In the pdf, scientology refers to the satirical youtube video which was created to spoof the crazy declarations that scietology has made about Anonymous including that they are guided by the communist manifesto and mein kampf. The video came out after scientology had tried to label Anonymous as communist nazis on the payroll of psychiatrists. Amazing. Also of great comedy value was the typical " what are your crimes" approach where the author of the letter tried to turn your genuine interest around on you by asking you outrageous questions. "Attack never defend" right scientology?
Great great job on the article. Thank you for being so brave. You have proven yourself to be a friend of humanity!
Posted by: amazed and laughing on March 18, 2008 6:10 PM
Truly a poor excuse for a researched story. How do you know that Anon members didn't make bomb threats? If there is no centralized leadership, how can you verify this? And why bother incorporating the response from the C of S spokesperson in your story, rather you relegate it to a link. I was at the event that also told of the establishment of the Harlem and Zimbabwe organizations. Rather than your contention that some minority is being targeted, the entire context was how to help areas that had a high incidence of social ills, drug abuse and illiteracy. Your ignorance of the theology of Scientology (you got the creation "myth" wrong also, which is publicly available in Hubbard's books and is called "The Factors"....and your bias in relying solely on individuals who have left the Church relegates this story to poorly written tabloid. Oh and I didn't see any mention of the nine new Churches just purchased and under renovation internationally to handle the growth of Scientology. Check back in say a year or two and compare notes, you'll find unprecedented expansion of Scientology globally.
Posted by: smarc on March 18, 2008 6:17 PM
This was an excellent and informative article. My understanding is that you asked organized scientology about apparent abuses by their leader David Miscavige. They denied he made any abuses. I personally worked with David Miscavige and have seen him spit on, punch in the mouth, choke and slap hard on the face staff. I also know others who have been beaten and otherwise physically abused by him. I know Miscavige to have lied in courts and to the IRS about his control of organized scientology and other matters. I know this from first hand experience. If called upon I would give testimony to this effect. I salute John Cook and Radar for their courage and integrity in taking on this litigious organization, Sincerely, Larry Brennan, New Hampshire, USA
Posted by: LarryB on March 18, 2008 6:40 PM
By the way, for more about Jenna Miscavige, she will be appearing on nightline on ABC. Maybe tonight (3/18)
Posted by: amazed and laughing on March 18, 2008 6:42 PM
Hands down the best article on this corrupt organisation since the Time magazine piece. Comprehensive, factual, and timely. You should be very proud of your efforts especially given the lack of hardcopy news coverage in the wake of the Morton book.
Posted by: MacFhearghuis on March 18, 2008 6:45 PM
Kudos, Mr. Cook, for honestly and accurately portraying the "church" of Scientology as it is, and the "anonymous" movement as I have seen it to be by lurking on forums all over the place.
So many of us bystanders (and participants, too) are extremely heartened that a few courageous journalists are telling the truth, and informing the public. It gives comfort to those who have left the cult, those who have been "fair gamed" by the cult, and those who seek to stop the cult's genocidal "master race" ideology.
I'll be on the lookout for Jenna Miscavige's interview, and all that follows. The serious, not-funny, and truly threatening cult of Scientology must be brought to account for its subversive and terroristic activites. Stop them, NOW, before it's too late for us all!.
Posted by: SoccerMom on March 18, 2008 7:14 PM
"And why bother incorporating the response from the C of S spokesperson in your story, rather you relegate it to a link. "
First of all, the author did use quotes from this response in the article. Second, rather than just leave it at quotes, he gives readers the opportunity to read the ENTIRE RESPONSE, a very large document, rather than just use a few quotes and then leave it at that. I thought this was more than fair. It's more like getting a whole other entire article for Scientology to defend themselves in, written by a top ranking Scientologist. More than fair.
Posted by: Aldanon on March 18, 2008 7:17 PM
Kudos for putting all this together into powerful article.
This is an excellent article, except for one thing. You should have trusted your instincts when you hesitated. You should have questioned Patricia Greenway and Peter Alexander further because if you had, you would have found out that they are subject to a very definitive injunction which, by bringing you to drive by and stroll the area, they seemed to have yet again courted the fringe of violating it and included you in it's potential violation.
The last person that happened be lured into something like this was the late Shawn Lonsdale... you can read about what happened to him when the church lawyers deposed him for "acting in concert with Patricia Greeneway the first time he met her while doing his Cult Watch protest :
What Really Happened to Shawn http://groups.google.com/group/alt.religion.scientology/msg/36b59e6063b04fba
I hope, for everyone's sake, that you are not deposed. It's bad enough that CoS has all those pictures of you on file now. In case no one mentioned it to you, you really need to warn you neighbors and local officials that there is potential for you to be framed or lied about, so precautiuons are important. Send them a copy of this article. And remember, all that glitters is not gold.
Posted by: Mary McConnell on March 18, 2008 7:53 PM
If you keep at the criticism, be sure and let Dave Touretzky, know. He'll want to help you with the sale of your website, like he did with Chris Owen's critical site. Big Pharma is Big Bucks, don't forget.
Posted by: Terryeo on March 18, 2008 8:29 PM
Oh man, I simply MUST get print copies of this! The 1991 Time Magazine issue of the Scientology crime syndicate's exposure is worth some real money these days so I'm going to get like 10 copies of this -- this is GREAT stuff! It's also great to see Patricia's name out there in Clearwater once again. Go Anonymous! Go ARSCC! We will dismantle the crime syndicate yet! My opinionsonly and only my opinions.
Posted by: DamOTclese on March 18, 2008 9:01 PM
By the way: Operation Reconnect will be the April effort to raise awareness of the Scientology corporation's deliberate assaults against families and how Scientology breaks apart families solely for money.
That web site is slated to be _the_ web site for details about how loved ones can try to find out where their sons, daughters, mothers, fathers, and anyone else who has disappeared inside the sinister Scientology corporation's barricaded walls have gone to -- and what to do about it.
My opinions only and only my opinions, as always.
Posted by: DamOTclese on March 18, 2008 9:10 PM
I would like to know why the US Dept of Justice and the FBI have done NOTHING to prevent the epic level of fraud, abuse and violence commited by the Corporation of Scientology.
If ever an Organization fits the bill for a Racketeering Influenced and Corrupt Organization, the "Church" of Scientology is certainly it!
It is high time for the US Dept of Justice and FBI along with the Attorneys General of California and Florida to rain down RICO Act indictments against the leadership of Scientology and its Medusa-like web of front companies.
Posted by: greyhound38 on March 18, 2008 10:56 PM
EEEWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW ! ! !
Patricia Greenway & P.A. insinuating themselves as "tour-guides" of Anonymous!?! How nauseating.
Beware Anonymous! Don't associate with them or you will be un-masked and slapped with a real live legal injunction.
The last guy who that happened to ended up dying under suspicous circumstances!
Posted by: Roan on March 18, 2008 11:34 PM
haha~~~interesting! i saw some more interesting pics about this on intimatemingle.com which is a dating site for interracial single.
Posted by: shangshine on March 19, 2008 12:34 AM
I saw part of the movie The Firm tonight and the unintentional irony blew me away.
Tom Cruise in a movie about someone getting trapped in a nefarious, ultra secret gangster-controlled cabal where anybody that tries to escape or speak out mysteriously ends up dead.
Oh the majestic irony.
Posted by: greyhound38 on March 19, 2008 2:07 AM
Thank you for your excellent and brave reporting. Kudos to you for posting the 10 page Scientology response, let people read both sides of the story and decide what to believe.
I note that a Scientologist has already made a veiled threat against your website. Remember that now there are thousands of people waiting to report and disseminate news of the dirty tactics of the OSA. If any harassment occurs, let the people know. Such harassment of those who tell the truth only serves to turn more people against the cult.
Posted by: UnnamedPerson on March 19, 2008 2:57 AM
If only every article about the protests were like this one... The movement grows. That's the best part about ultra-paranoid organizations with illogical principles that forbid interpretation, they always go down spectacularly.
Posted by: anon5555 on March 19, 2008 2:58 AM
My God! Once again, radar did a famous job analysing the structures of the cult and its opponents activity to get it down or reformed.
Now, some things VERY important happened in France these last months as well.
Indeed, an ex-cult member was sequestrated for months by cult's members, in three locations. She was found almost nude by italian police in a home rented by his scientology brother, unable to walk at 48, sleeping on a squalid mattress, in a void room, and was sent to an hospital before being sent back to France where she complained against John Doe.
Five scientologists were involved in her "introspection rundown" treatment, the same that killed Lisa McPherson inClearwater on Dec 5, 1995.
Besides of this, the cuolt is lobbying some politicians since decades, so as to be recognized as a religion, being tax-exempt, and not under some enquiry of state offices. But alas for them, the President, the Prime Minister and other politicians or officials have then been better informed about the facts, and further, Anonymous people came then to rescue.
Now, the cult in France is really concentrating on some ways - some lies more - to avoid a high court (Assises) criminal trial as well as a method to make believe that it's so great... Since it's also waiting for a very important criminal trial in Belgium - soon to be started - one can now say that it'll get what's coming to it!
In France, we say "numéroter tes abattis", that means that a person 'has to count and number her bones', a way to allegate that the cult could come to pieces.
Posted by: rogergonnet on March 19, 2008 3:46 AM
TO ALL READERS OF THIS COMMENT SECTION...
YOU WILL NOTICE A POST BY A "PERSON" NAMED TERRYEO, THIS IS NOT PERSON BUT A CATCH-ALL NAME USED BY SEVERAL OF THE OSA CRIMINALS WITHIN SCIENTOLOGY. THIS, FOR SOME REASON, IS ONE OF THEIR FAV. ON-LINE NAMES AND IF YOU GOOGLE TERRYEO YOU'LL FIND DOZENS OF ITS POSTING.
Posted by: Centurian 10 on March 19, 2008 10:05 AM
Mr Cook, I think you wetre lied to :
"Greenway and Alexander have steered clear of downtown Clearwater for several months and fear that if they're spotted in the area, the Church will unleash private investigators on them (as they claim it has in the past), and that a new wave of troubling phone calls and attempts to meddle with their business will commence. This strikes me as paranoid."
You see, they were spotted at the previous protest. Here in this IRC log someone sent me, we find Patricia Greenway ( TFCVP and then as GypsyQueen ) admitting that she was indeed there last month on Feb 19th 2008! :
Session Start: Fri Feb 29 20:01:16 2008
Session Ident: #altreligionscientology
* Now talking in #altreligionscientology
* Topic is 'New website launch: http:// www.exscientologykids.com collaboration between Astra Woodcraft, Jenna Miscavige Hill and Kendra Wiseman. '
* Set by Teeg on Thu Feb 28 22:41:09
* X sets mode: +l 28
[..]
* TFCVP has joined #altreligionscientology
greetings
speak of the Queen of the Gypsies herself!
LOL
* TheSneakster huggles TFCVP :)
Hi there, TFCVP, we're all reading/talking about the post.
greetings o satan of the buttersquash gypsies
ok...let me change my costume
* TFCVP is now known as GypsyQueen
henri: that's *Ms.* Satan, to you.
* Teeg breaks out the tambourines
LOL
I thought everyone knew the Devil Wears Prada
;-)
Sure, we'll sit around and do D'Jango versions of appropriate songs.
I was wearing Prada today...but the perfume
so I qualify
see ?\
:D
;P
ok, so I didn't mean to interrupt
We can do a spirited verson of "After You've Gone."
what say "youse"? regarding the letters?
prada?
I just started reading henri's post.
or is there ANYBODY here who wants to ASK me anything?
I'm still catching up with the thread on ARS some of the references.
since people don't bother to ASK me anything...they just buy into LermaLoon's lies
I have nothing to ask...
except, Mir...?
where's your briefcase of Minton money
right?
LOL
f*****'s never sent my money
it's very clear and really, I don't have a question now. I have questions as to why people can be as dumb as wood.
the only person who sent me money was the gypsies :)
henri: another thing these drooling, gibbering zombie morons have overlooked.... regarding the Power Of Attorney ?
god, they really are zombies, aren't they
persons / gypsies.
Minton can revoke it at any time.
* znalo beats head against wall
Oh...and I'd like to clear up a couple other "lermalies"
[..]
YES, i drove by the Clearwater picket on Feb 10th...that's true...NEVER got out of the car...we picked up 3 tails soon as we got near
downtown--one of them being Richard Hirsch
because he's scientology's bitch
because the cult's got his balls in a vise.
if the lawyer is not doing what he wishes, please ?
and thus NOBODY boo'd me or us
hirst
that NEVER happened
these people really are idiots
i wonder, how would lerma know that anyway
so that's another LERMALIE
did stacy tell him that from OSA?
"is there any evidence his hands weren't bound by intimidation or fear"
yeah but how'd he know you even drove by?
well, I tracked it back to Mary OUt her ASS
that's interesting tfc
she was the first to post that shit about being BOO'd "
I posted on alt.religion.scientology usenet that I was told she's been there and got out of the car and was boo'd but she never had the guts to post a denial.
Someone sent me this because she was talking about me and that post.
I'm glad I have allies who have my back, and to pay it forward, I am posting this here for your protection.
Posted by: Mary McConnell on March 19, 2008 12:08 PM
oops, that didn't post correctly. The nic names for who says what are missing. I'll just email it to the author and editor,
If anyone wants a copy of that part of the log, email me at
xscilentologist at yahoo dot com
Posted by: Mary McConnell on March 19, 2008 12:33 PM
Excellent article. Radar gets anonymous and Scientology correctly. Good job.
Regarding me pointing out the comparison of Mike Rinder's relationship to Scientology like Goebel's relationship was to Naziism, I have to say I don't dislike Mike Rinder as a person.
I actually like him, and my tiny few dealings with him over the years, very minor, I respected him, he was fair and balanced with me.
I recognize that Mike took on a really tough role in Scientology's history, Commanding Officer of the Office of Special Affairs, a sub bureaucratic unit of lifetime top administrators entrusted to carry out Hubbard's most disgraceful propagandizing, dirty tricks, Private Eye hiring, legal suit harassment, etc, he did hold the head honcho role in the last decade off and on.
So it's parallel to view him as important as a Goebells was to Naziism, but I don't think Mike would go along for the truly horrendous level of despicable violence of Naziism.
Mike from what I have heard was mostly on the receiving end of David Miscavige's fad trend of petty violence that over the last almost 3 decades has plagued top ranks staff in Scientology.
Mike from what I've learned, did NOT engage in the petty internal violence so much. He accepted his slappings and harrangues from David Miscavige, and Mike didn't in turn dramatize this on his underlings as far as I know. So good on Mike for getting out of the top ranks insanity that goes on under David Miscavige currently.
David Miscavige likes to have others assume and share his style of irrational behavior, and I don't think Mike went along with it.
Others who in the end opted out, rather than play the David Miscavige irrational role model, are Steve Marlowe, Marty Rathbun (Marty being even more senior and trusted than Mike Rinder).
At least Scientology top ranks men and women decide enough is enough, and they opt OUT of top ranks Scientology, rather than play the vicious staff to staff bashing game!
Good on all those top ranks staff who got out.
Now, I hope they as a group in hindsight will firsthand detail just how bad it all is!!
Jeff Hawkins has been speaking up.
Now the even higher ranked members who put up with the vicious top level insanities should just lay it all out and air the mess and let Miscavige get HIS due!
I see ebbs and flows of fads of "asshole" behavior, over the decades I was in the movement. I think to Mike Rinder's credit he overall didn't become a full blown bastard to other staff.
I like Mike, and I'll publicly apologize to him, and I hope he goes public someday. I think the whole top level staff who opted OUT of Scientology top ranks ought to go public.
Chuck Beatty
ex Scientology staffer (1975-2003)
412-260-1170 Pittsburgh, USA (anyone call me anytime!)
http://www.freewebs.com/chuckbeatty77/
http://tinyurl.com/295khy
http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/05205/542899.stm
http://tinyurl.com/38ptz8 buffalo video
http://tinyurl.com/ywhgaf buffalo poster
Posted by: chuckbeatty77 on March 19, 2008 1:05 PM
I love Scieno apologists like smarc that keep popping up in forums like those at exscientologykids.com and then say it's dumb to only rely on ex member testimony.
Yes, by all means let's have the press go poking around Scientoogy and asking questions about all the people that have died or disappeared as well as the criminal tactics and fraudulant business dealings that go on there. Since Scientology is as open and transparent as you suggest let's go looking.
Oh yeah, sorry I forgot. Scientology threatens and harrasses anybody that tries to find out the truth and asks questions they don't like.
Why not trust Jenna Miscavige? She's only part of the Royal Family of Scientology? Why would she bolt the church. live like a criminal on the run and work like a dog at an entry-level job starting a new life if David Miscavige and the Scientology Corporation were so wonderful?
Kind of interesting that Jenna coroborates everything the critics have been saying for decades PLUS a whole bunch of other info on child abuse and neglect we knew nothing about? Is BIG Pharmaceutical paying her under the table? I doubt it.
And the fallacious question "How do you know that Anon members didn't make bomb threats?"
Well, let's see. The fact that Scientology routinely makes bomb threats against itself would be a good start. See the FBI information regarding Paulette Cooper and Operation Freakout where they used her typing paper with her fingerprints to type up phoney bomb threats which were used to frame her to the FBI. Oh no... Scientology certainly wouldn't stoop to dirty tricks like that.
Sorry smarc and TERRYEO. I'm afraid the cat is now TOTALLY out of the bag. Corporation of Scientology's days are numbered. They are the source of their own undoing. Federal RICO Act indictments will one day come down on Co$ leadership like hail.
Posted by: greyhound38 on March 19, 2008 1:08 PM
Thanks for this. I attended the Chicago protest with my son last Saturday. Unfortunately we were harassed by police and made to leave the area despite having been assured by the city that we did not need a permit to picket the Scio building on Lincoln Ave. I guess I should be glad that we weren't confronted by police in full riot gear and actual arrests, as was the case in Atlanta.
BTW, for the most comprehensive information on the Scientology protests, be sure to visit Enturbulation.org. That is all.
Posted by: Anonymom on March 19, 2008 5:11 PM
Thanks to Radar and to John Cook for an excellent article.
As I former scientologist, I can verify that this article is very accurate.
I have often wondered how scientology has gotten away with its primitive and abusive treatment of children.
As to Matt Feshbach and the super power rundown: Feshbach's claim of superpowers in saving the life of a young boy by stopping him from running into the street is downright silly.
Parents have been keeping their children from running into the streets for centuries. I myself have kept many children from running into the streets but I didn't realize that this was a superpower - more like common sense.
Posted by: veritas on March 19, 2008 9:06 PM
Still waiting for some journalist to have the cojones to investigate the links between *some of* Anonymous's original cast to kiddy porn and child molestation.
I've seen the sites with their chatter. I saw an admission of it in a YouTube post by a longtime anti-Scientology poster there. I saw an Anonymous "call to arms" (cute) that ended with some phrase like, "When we're done (with the protest) we'll all go eat delicious cake." "Delicious cake" is code for either cp (child pornography) or molestation.
There's a story there, guys. Or are you afraid Anon will hack your Web site -- like they did Fox News -- if you get into their private unpardonable pedophilic penchants and personal proclivities?
And...you slid right over the fact that to deliver a DDOS (distributed denial of service) attack. But props for mentioning that it was "distributed"; most media didn't. The hackers had to be running a botnet of innocent people's distributed PCs they had hijacked to send the packets that crashed Scientology's sites.
f you're going to carry a keyboard for a living, you owe us all sides of the story.
Posted by: Him on March 20, 2008 2:58 AM
""Delicious cake" is code for either cp (child pornography) or molestation."
Hahahaha, you've got to be kidding me, hahaha.
Any CP on Anonymous related boards/wiki's is almost instantly deleted and the poster is banned until the year 9999, in which you will probably still be working at the Sea Org, since you guys sign contracts for a billion years, right? Hahahaha, you fail it.
Posted by: Hahahaha on March 20, 2008 6:19 AM
Heh, Delicious Cake is code for Child Pornography now? Quick, someone tell http://www.deliciouscake.com !
What a ridiculous thing to claim, the term is based out of one of two things: The game portal which makes repeated comical references to cake (are we to believe Valve is made up of Pedophiles now?) which is also a reference to the second thing: The largely unexplained infatuation with all things random on the internet. Be it Cake, Pie or lolcattery.
Memes are not secret codes, they're just Web injokes.
You're probably just another scientologist propagating lies in an attempt to discredit people who disagree with you.
Fair play. Pun intended.
Posted by: JamesR on March 20, 2008 6:44 AM
That's so cute! All unpleasant truths are "Scientology lies." And no one in Anonymous has done ehhnnything wrong.
Yup "delicious cake" is a meme, too.
Try looking at things with both eyes. Or is it more comfy to close one, so you have no messy real-life contradictions to deal with?
Here's a cool vid!
http://youtube.com/watch?v=4Pwq3EtdelY&watch_response
Bet you'll like to read its chatter and reach for the olive oil!
Here's one of my favorite comments under that vid: "Only a minority of Anon are paedophiles."
Btw, that was all I said. No massive condemnations.
Good company you keep. And of course your boards get cleaned up...now that the world is watching.
May your children never know you...biblically.
Giggles and grinz!
Posted by: Him on March 20, 2008 12:56 PM
Oh wow, lets make a video and disable ratings and force comment approval! That's how you do things at the Co$, right?
"And of course your boards get cleaned up...now that the world is watching."
Hahaha, too bad it's been like that since the beginning. And trust me, the CP shit is a stupid lie, since it's so easily verified, so I suggest you try another. Perhaps some more of the 'hate crimes' and such!
Good luck on the bridge, and on to OTIII, right? Hail Xenu!
Posted by: Hahahaha on March 20, 2008 7:59 PM
The point here is that those who just go on demonstrations because they're fun or cool are nearly always unaware of the darker side of some of their instigators. That can lead to some relatively innocent people getting busted by association.
*Something* must be going on for you to get so angry so fast at a simple statement of fact that specifically stated it dealt with "*some of*" Anon's organizers. It wasn't even knowingly directed at you.
But I fault myself for not making this point more clearly: Author John Cook does neither himself, nor his publishers, nor you any favors by so clearly taking sides and omitting facts that you and more casual readers have a right to know.
Actually, you probably already knew the criminal nature of Anonymous's acts, but many don't.
But a writer does his craft and profession--and his own credibility in future articles--a large disservice by writing one-sided articles. If his next article on a different topic offends you, you now have ammo to point out he's intellectually dishonest.
If he took any journalism courses, his profs taught him differently. Serious reporters, even if they're evaluating the new iPod, need to be honest and inclusive of all sides of the story.
And before you begin the rote litany about Scientology's crimes," here's my invitation: Prove Anything. Prove Something.
There were some fanatics who went overboard and broke Church policy in the 1970's--that's nearly 40 years ago. No argument there. But that level of personality has been straightened out or expelled. We did the house-cleaning.
So come up to present time. Look at what really exists around you today.
And stay in countries where there's religious freedom. Yes, you can look to Germany for that Gestapo government's recent condemnation of Scientology. But look deeper and you'll see that its churches and psychiatrists are pushing that movement--and for good reason!
Churches in Germany get money directly by voluntary payroll deduction, whether people go to church or not. And no bishop wants to lose those cash cows because too many people become Scientologists.
Thus endeth the epistle!
ml,
H
Posted by: Him on March 21, 2008 10:34 AM
Hey Him, here's an epistle by your idol L Ron Hubbard , about his friend, Aliester Crowley.
From PDC tape #18 (Dec 5, 1952)
"Now, he could simply say, "I have action." A magician - the magic cults of the eighth, ninth, tenth, eleventh, twelfth centuries in the Middle East were fascinating. The only modern work that has anything to do with them is a trifle wild in spots, but it's fascinating work in itself, and that's work written by Aleister Crowley, the late Aleister Crowley, my very good friend. And he did himself a splendid piece of aesthetics built around those magic cults. It's very interesting reading to get hold of a copy of a book, quite rare, but it can be obtained. the Master Therion, T-h-e-r-i-o-n, The Master Therion by Aleister Crowley. He signs himself "The Beast"; "The Mark of the Beast, 666." Very, very something or other."
You can listen to Hubbard say this himself : http://www.xenu.net/archive/media_vault/Crowley.mp3
Operation Clambake present:
Hubbard Audio Collection ( Lot's of audio clips by the racist, antichristian LRH)
http://www.xenu.net/archive/multimedia.html
Posted by: Mary McConnell on March 21, 2008 12:47 PM
For an appalling, hilarious, and eye-opening bio of "LRH," go here:
http://www.clambake.org/archive/books/bfm/bfmconte.htm
Well-written, droll, and thorough.
Posted by: Hoodia Love on March 22, 2008 12:18 PM
Haha why are are Scientology apologists so predictable? Of course John Cook must be a religious bigot. Just like Anonymous are religious bigots. Just like anyone who criticizes the "corp" are religious bigots.
I think it's funny how much Karin Pouw asserted "we are growing and expanding". Yet in fact no one is joining, their orgs are emptier than ever. They have been calling up people who have been out of the organization up to thirty years, they are so desperate. They are begging people to come in and get back on course.
Of course they have lied about their membership numbers for years-anyone who has ever taken a course is considered a member. By that count they are still counting Charles Manson who had the sense to leave Scientology because he thought it was too crazy. what does that say about it?
"There were some fanatics who went overboard and broke Church policy in the 1970's--that's nearly 40 years ago. No argument there. But that level of personality has been straightened out or expelled. We did the house-cleaning."
So many ways which this is untrue.
Notice "Him" doesn't even address what these people did?
There was a concerted effort, a policy effort on the part of the "Church" to infiltrate the US Government, steal documents, blackmail IRS agents, and wirtap offices. This effort involved thousands of Scienotologists on direct orders fron L Ron Hubbard(who was named an unidicted coconspirator by the FBI). 11 high level members, including Hubbard's wife were convicted in 1980.
Him claims that these people were "housecleaned". Well, obviously they never housecleaned Hubbard(although I suppose little Davey Miscavige is making a good attempt at that now with all of his squirreling of the tech). But the convicted members were just transferred to other positions just a little more hidden.
That was "Operation Snowwhite". Of course there was also "Operation Freakout" where a reporter wrote a story they didn't like and she was framed by them for bomb threats. Sound familiar? The FBI proved that they were deliberately trying to make her go crazy by harassment. They even went so far as to steal her fingereprints to plant on a letter. How sick is that documented fact?
And of course, L Ron Hubbard was convicted of fraud in absentia in France in 1978. That's why he spent his time running for the last several years of his life. Some hero.
But yes moving on from 1980 : just noting a few things(hardly an inclusive list),
1989: USA: Scientology Found Guilty of Inflicting Emotional Distress
In 1986, former Scientologist Larry Wollersheim sued Scientology for intentional infliction of emotional distress. The jury awarded him $35,000,000, which was reduced on appeal to $2,500,000. Scientology refuses to pay, and now owes Larry more than twice that (with interest accruing).
The appeals court agreed that Larry had been badly hurt by Scientology: it found that Scientology "coerced Wollersheim into continued participation," "seized Wollersheim and held him captive," and that "the Church's conduct was manifestly outrageous." In October 1997, the court found that the Church of Scientology International and Religious Technology Center are liable for the debt.
1992: Canada: Scientology found guilty of breach of the public trust
Scientology itself and three Scientology executives were found guilty of breach of public trust in a case involving the theft of information from government offices(a similar effort to infiltrate the eCanadian government).
1994: USA: Scientology fined for filing a frivolous lawsuit
Helena Kobrin, representing RTC (a Scientology corporation), was fined $17,775 for filing a frivolous lawsuit. (Using the law to harass critics is Scientology policy.)
1995: Canada: Scientology pays the largest libel award in Canadian history
Scientology was found guilty of libelling Casey Hill, the prosecutor responsible for bringing Scientology to justice for its egregious illegal acts in Canada.
1996: France: Scientologists guilty of interfering with a witness
Three Scientologists were given suspended prison sentences for interfering with an expert witness in a Lyon trial. Charges of theft were proven.
1996: France: Scientology executive found guilty of involuntary homicide
"A former Church of Scientology leader was convicted Friday of involuntary homicide and sentenced to 18 months in prison in the 1988 suicide of a church member. Twelve other defendants facing lesser charges - theft, complicity or abuse of confidence - were given suspended sentences of eight to 15 months each. Charges were dropped against 10 others." The Scientologists were charged in the death of Patrice Vic.
1997: Italy: Scientologists jailed
29 Scientologists were sentenced to jail for criminal association.
1999: Greece: Scientologists found guilty
15 Scientologists were accused of systematically keeping files on politicians, journalists, judges, clergymen and other Greek leading personalities. The Scientologists were found guilty, but they were not sentenced, due to procedural errors. (In other words, they got off on a technicality.)
In 1998, a judge ordered the Scientology organization in Athens to stop operating, since the organization was established under false pretenses. According to the ruling, the organization was not operating as a non-profit, and was putting people's mental and physical health at risk.
So many many crimes! How about as little as a month ago, in Italy where French Scientologists had kidnapped a woman and held her against her will on the order of one of the highest level Scientologists in France? She like Lisa McPherson, was held in squalid conditions, biting by bugs, not fed and denied medication or proper care. Do you even care?
This is not a cult that wants to keep to itself. The real danger as can be seen by the repeated efforts to infiltrate and subvert governments across the world is that this is not random action, but policy, to acheive its goals. This is why we cannot sit in a corner and say oh let's just laugh at the craziness.
Him, you do not know your "Church". You have been told lies. But yes let's look at the crimes and what the courts across the world have said. Yes please Him, do look.
Posted by: katherine noelle on March 22, 2008 4:51 PM
Yeah, and it's the Muslims that are going to "destroy this country from the inside out"... That's fantastic.
I'm sorry but besides the fact that I go to a pretty much Islamic community to get my monthly need for Arabic food, I have yet to see anybody watching me from buildings with a video camera. But maybe I should look now, seeing as what these people are doing.
Who's the radical? Who's dangerous?
Is it my Muslim friends and neighbors or is it these people that basically took over a city and considered the rest of us "infidels"?
There's more than one type of "radical" and apparently after reading this article, they're all not reading the "Quaran" nor wearing a hijab. They're your neighbors that wear khakis and polos yet will act as one of the "Stepford Wives".
Evil is as Evil does. WAKE UP AMERICA!!! Different doesn't mean evil! Evil means evil... even if it comes in the form of Tom Cruise.
Let me know when the spaceship arrives.... I'll be praying to God/Allah to save me.
Posted by: leilani on March 22, 2008 10:44 PM
I read on another website that scientology has a larger file on them than even Al Capone (notorious US mobster) does. That's certainly saying something right there. (foia.fbi.gov reading room)
narCONon
Narconon likes to flaunt a high success rate for it's drug rehabilitation front for scientology. This is all based off of a single non-peer-reviewed study done in Sweden in 1981 by one Peter Gerdman. Now this single study was done back in the early 1980s and was not peer reviewed before publication. The basic flaw in the study was that the statistics gathered were based on what scientologists running the narconon program told the person or people performing the study, there is no way to verify if they were telling the truth or not.
Scientology's facts about narconon all stem from this single non-peer-reviewed study. The lowest figure that has been published claims at least a 70% success rate.
Now let us look at the figures again, after the study became public in Sweden and was subjected to independent review.
61 individuals entered the programme, of whom
24 left during detoxification;
23 left during other stages;
14 completed the programme.
The overall completion rate was thus 23%.
That's not really 70%+ as claimed, amazing!
Furthermore:
77% of those who enrolled on the course quit before completing it.
50% of those who did complete it went back onto drugs afterwards (and another 14% somewhat mysteriously didn't know if they had or not).
54% of those interviewed afterwards who did not complete it went back onto drugs.
34% of enrollees said they had completed the programme and relapsed but claimed to be drug free at the moment.
6.6% of enrollees said they had stayed totally drug free for one year afterwards.
Narconon's literature plays down other programs by claiming they have success rates of 15% or lower. But even a quick investigation of their own study shows pretty clearly that they are doing worse than other programs (many of which are absolutely free to participate in), and that's if scientology's figures for their "competitors" is even accurate.
"narconon recidivism rate" is what led me to Dave Touretzky's website. His website has been successfully defended from lawsuit(s?) brought on by scientology. You can't win a libel/slander suit against someone if the information is true.
A large majority of people speaking out against scientology have years and years of court records and undeniable proof behind them. Scientology prefers to stick to calling critics names such as bigot, nazi, kkk, etc.
In this age of information, if you cannot back up your claims you have no right to be making them.
Anonymous is information. Scientology is lies and deception.
Posted by: jeffersonbclark on March 23, 2008 4:00 AM
Him Quoteth:
"*Something* must be going on for you to get so angry so fast at a simple statement of fact that specifically stated it dealt with "*some of*" Anon's organizers. It wasn't even knowingly directed at you."
smells like projection :)
http://sexual.taxexemptchildabuse.net/
So tell me Him, What are your crimes? What crimes have you covered up today?
Posted by: Darwins Chihuahua on March 23, 2008 6:45 PM
Not to get insanely paranoid here, but the question that comes up in my mind right now...How do we know that Jenna Miscavige and Mike Rinder's "defections" from Scientology are not in fact a massive "fair game" maneuver? Maybe I've watched Orson Welles' MR. ARKADIN too many times, but what better way to lure all the church's enemies out of the shadows and into target range than by sending some meaty "apostates" to befriend them?
Posted by: The Hoyk on March 24, 2008 9:21 AM
The Hoyk, you are an idiot. I'm sorry. Grownups are trying to talk here be gone.
Anyway, now for some smart talk. As a former Scientologist, who is technically still in the Cult (but no longer a believer or paying customer), I can attest to the manny high crimes that Scientology has committed against private citizens of the United States. Unfortunately their campaign of intimidating critics has let them stay in the shadows where they could flourish, because they knew sunlight would kill it instantly.
All these accusations against Anonymous are untrue. If they are such terrorists then why haven't local police departments corroborated all these threats and incidents of violence they keep citing? And what of the video that Scientologists point to that they supposedly got off youtube? Don't ignore the fact that the supposed youtube video is way too high definition and widescreen to have come from youtube. An intelligent mind would conclude it was a Scientology fabrication.
Watch this and decide for yourself
http://www.vimeo.com/824772
I am currently in the process of gathering incriminating evidence using my position on the inside in order to whistleblow. I have watched this tyranny go on for far too long
inb4bgodley
Posted by: bgodley on March 26, 2008 7:11 PM
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
Posted by: fgsfds on March 28, 2008 11:50 PM
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
Posted by: fgsfds on March 28, 2008 11:51 PM
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESU
DESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDESUDES
Can we get a list of the questions you submitted to Scientology in which they answered in the pdf? I'd like to know what they're responding to.
Second. Question 14 gives a source for "Anonymous has publicly proclaimed its guiding materials to be the Communist Manifesto and Mein Kampf" however it fails to mention that the first instance of these Contradictory Ideals appearing anywhere in relation to anonymous was Scientology itself proclaiming it at least 3 days earlier. Source: http://www.sptimes.com/2008/02/07/Southpinellas/Church_of_Scientology.shtml
By branding normal people who only want to speak out about the abuses against our democracy by Scientology as "terrorists" they only prove the point. It's fear mongering of the first degree.