EXCLUSIVE: Dr. Phil Asks Judge To Dismiss Dog Bite Lawsuit
Posted on Mar 14, 2011 @ 07:00PM
Talk show host, Dr. Phil McGraw, is fighting back at allegations by a former best friend who claims she was severely bitten by McGraw’s beloved family dog.
In the court documents, obtained exclusively by RadarOnline.com, Dr. Phil’s attorneys are demanding that the lawsuit be dismissed because it’s in violation of an agreement to arbitrate any disputes.
EXCLUSIVE DOCUMENTS: Dr. Phil request lawsuit be dismissed.
RadarOnline.com broke the exclusive story about the lawsuit pitting former best friends against each other.
According to the response filed March 7, Dr. Phil’s attorneys state that the alleged victim, Janet Harris allegedly signed an arbitration agreement in 2009 that stated in part: “I [Janet Harris] agree that any and all disputes, now existing or hereafter arising, between me…and Dr. Phillip McGraw and/or Robin McGraw… will be resolved exclusively and solely in a binding, confidential, private arbitration….”
EXCLUSIVE PHOTOS: See Injuries Caused By Bite From Dr. Phil's Dog
The McGraws are seeking an order to dismiss Harris’ lawsuit and settle the lawsuit in arbitration.
Harris was frequently featured on the Dr. Phil’s talk show as a skin care specialist and became a close confidant of the McGraws. Her lawsuit contends that she traveled with the McGraws for business and pleasure, spent holidays with them and more.
PHOTOS: Dr. Phil Shaves Off His Mustache
But all of that changed when Harris visited the McGraw's Beverly Hills home in late 2009 and Maggie, their Korean Jindo, allegedly attacked Harris "without provocation and warning," according to the complaint filed February 2 by Harris' personal injury lawyer, Larry Nagelberg.
Harris states in her filing that the dog bit her right hand and arm so hard she bled.
PHOTOS: Puppy Love: Stars and Their Dogs
According to the complaint, Robin offered to take Harris to the hospital, but Dr. Phil instructed his wife not to because it would create "unnecessary" bad press and he wanted to handle it privately.
So in lieu of seeking medical treatment at a hospital, Harris was prescribed antibiotics by a physician through a nurse friend, but the next day her arm was swollen, the documents state.
PHOTOS: Oprah And Her Famous Friends
The lawsuit claims that after getting a Tetanus shot, Harris was forced to take IV antibiotics and had to see an infectious disease specialist who diagnosed her with pastuerella multocida -- a disease caused by an animal bite.
Harris says in her lawsuit that the dog bite injury caused the infection and that it would have been fatal if she had not been placed on antibiotics within 72 hours.
PHOTOS: Couples We’d Like To See!
The lawsuit further states that her medical conditions hindered her ability to work and she was subsequently evicted and forced to close her Beverly Hills clinic.
Harris is seeking an unspecified monetary amount in damages, including all medical-related expenses.
RELATED STORIES:
VIDEO: Victim Of Dr. Phil Dog Attack Speaks Out: 'They Just Turned Their Backs And Walked Away'
EXCLUSIVE DOCUMENTS: Dr. Phil Sued By Best Friend For Dog Attack
Dr. Phil Selling Beverly Hills Mega Mansion
- Beyonce's Returning To The Stage For The First Time Since Becoming A Mom — Huffington Post
- Sienna Miller & Her Baby Bump Are All Smiles — The Frisky
- Jay-Z To Score New "Annie" Movie Starring Willow Smith — Global Grind
- Simon Cowell Asks 'What Was I Thinking?' After Choosing Britney Spears & Demi Lovato for 'X Factor' — Celebuzz
- Anne Hathaway's Ex Raffaello Follieri Released from Jail — Just Jared
- Age Appropriate? Kylie Minogue, 43, Dons Racy Webbed Dress — Celebuzz
- Click Here & Join Our Facebook Page — Facebook
Sample Header
The Daily Juice
Well its interesting that they say she was bit in her right arm so why is there a photo of her left?
Posted Tue, 03/15/2011 - 1:48am
But surely she doesn't expect him to
put their beloved dog down for not much more than a nip? It's true, any dog is capable
of being frightened or of just being protective. I would put the dog away
when others come to the house. End of story.
Posted Tue, 03/15/2011 - 1:03am
Since Dr. Phil will probably pick the "neutral" arbitrator, she may end up having to apologize to the dog.
Posted Mon, 03/14/2011 - 8:13pm
Is there anyone out there who really cares about this story? I thought I read that McGraw paid for all of her medical expenses. Slow news day I guess.
Posted Mon, 03/14/2011 - 7:28pm
Court of Public Opinion seems to be voting Dr. Phil GUILTY! I'm a huge dog lover but this isn't the first time this dog has bitten/attacked. Hope the grandbaby is safe!
Posted Mon, 03/14/2011 - 7:16pm
I hope the judge laughs this gold digger right out of court. Give me a break!
Posted Mon, 03/14/2011 - 6:51pm
Dr, Phil doesn't care about anyone except his family. His shows are becoming more and more exploitive of the troubled and less fortunate, especially women. His ego is almost as big as he's becoming.
Posted Mon, 03/14/2011 - 6:37pm
Bad juju, Dr PhD, very bad juju...
Posted Mon, 03/14/2011 - 6:21pm
Phil is such a hypocrite, pretending to care about people.. he's too consumed by greed to help anyone or take care of his own responsibilities.
Posted Mon, 03/14/2011 - 5:58pm
Gee, Dr Phil, no homeowners insurance?
Posted Mon, 03/14/2011 - 5:41pm