left arrow BackNext right arrow
< BACK TO Fresh Intelligence

An Extremely Brief History Of Blog Feuds

blogfeuds.jpg
"Blog fights are stupid, airing personal grievances in public is stupid, picking troll wars is stupid," wrote Boing Boinger Xeni Jardin today, in that site's explanation of removing its posts about a sex blogger (and California court trademark litigant). But are they? Aren't they actually awesome?

In 1999, wrote Rebecca Blood, something happened: "Cults of personality sprung up as new blogs appeared." More blogs were being born as diaries, instead of link-oriented lists. And that's when the stupid troll wars began.

Not long after, Dan Hartung started a feud with the anti-change crowd:

For blog critics, writing from your point of view is considered egotism. I even saw someone quit weblogging because he felt there was something wrong with writing statements that were not immediately challenged, an interesting social phenomenon born perhaps of chat rooms and newsgroups.

I see these potshots and I'm flabbergasted. We're to bury ourselves? We're to wait until we have something Important(tm) to say before speaking? Until our design is an award-winner?

I say, Go to hell. I mean it.

So yes, that happened. And what no one remembers from this era also is the proliferation of web-based reality shows. There was Puppetmaster, Survivorblog, and much, much worse. The entire point of these games was feuding. All of the details escape me now as this was basically the 1940s.

Some notable feuding since:

• 2001 and 2002: With the emergence of "the warbloggers" post-9/11, as they were called, everyone feuded with everyone. Seriously. Everyone! (N.B. that account includes some serious misreading.) It was sheer chaos, a mass freakout that distended psychoanalytic space and time. There were even Denial of Service attacks. Dave Winer, the feudiest of all internetters, took on the world, briefly.

• 2003: Everyone feuded with RSS-pusher Dave Winer. Dave Winer feuded with everyone. Someone somewhere hated on Salon.

Redhead aficionado Joe Clark started and/or finished a million feuds.

This and every year to follow: what was the first weblog? Fight, fight, fight!

• 2004: Gothamist publisher Jake Dobkin and blog entrepreneur Jason Calacanis go apeshit on each other. Previously, the Silicon Alley internet feud system basically looked like this handy diagram. In the latest case of Calacanis v. ____, Jake apologized, for some reason, after a transcript of their IM session became public, in which Calacanis asked "how dare you say shit about my mother" and "you are fucking asshole piece of shit." Wrote a commenter: "This is like two kids in prep school having an editor's war in their own self-published student newsletters."

Nick Denton, Maer Roshan, a pie.

Jonah Goldberg et al versus Andrew Sullivan. Apparently Sullivan did not make clear his reservations about George Bush on his blog before writing about them in The Advocate! And then Jonah promptly retracted it, because in fact Sullivan had already blogged about his "feelings." Still, conservative bloggers freaked out.

• 2006: Lee Siegel utilized sockpuppetry in his feud with the evils of blog commenters.

Michael Hiltzik, a Pulitzer Prize-winning reporter at the LA Times, was canned from his blog and suspended after leaving anonymous comments on the blog of a Los Angeles assistant district attorney; the two were feuding over something or other.

David Sirota and Dan Gerstein, two Democratic operatives, went head to head and then took their enmity into the feud that was the Lieberman-Lamont race, which was a headlong descent into the gutter for everyone involved.

• 2007: Jason Calacanis phoned in his third or eighth blog feud, this time with likely suspect Dave Winer. Winer, amazingly, semi-apologized.

Mickey Kaus v. Ezra Klein zzzzzz....

The strange case of Andrew Wright versus Andrew Wright: a comedian and a painter of the same name squabbled it out over domain names.

Cathy Seipp takes on Nikki Finke: "I haven't seen Nikki in years, probably because these days she looks like Jabba the Hut, if you can imagine Jabba after he's said to hell with the diets already."

Why don't web conferences represent women? (See also: every year previously.)

In a slightly more harrowing conflict, Eric Alterman and Ana Marie Cox went head-to-head over why Time magazine can't have a liberal columnist.

• 2008: Keith Gessen posted some pictures of puppies.

Wait! You forgot the famous bears versus monkeys Radar feud that's happening right now and really I will keep this going all through your vacation Balk and you'll be lying on the beach, sweating and cursing the glare of the sun in a cloudless sky off the white sand drinking some sort of blue beverage (I take you for a blue beverage man, Balk, and I bet you put the paper umbrella behind your ear after two or three drinks and maybe you giggle a little and comment quietly to yourself about how fetching you are!) and thinking to yourself "Fuck [sorry, can I swear here?], I just know that my Biggest Fan, jolie, who I really do love and adore so much even though she drives me to the brink of insanity nearly every day of my miserable existence from wondering 'Why? Why me? Why did she decide I was a worthy object of her obsession?' [ed. - I ask myself this every day], is type-type-typing something about monkeys and DAMN IT WHY CAN'T I EVER GET A BREAK?!?"

Posted by: jolie on July 1, 2008 4:51 PM

Choire, how could you leave out Eater vs. Down By The Hipster?

http://gawker.com/370643/foodblogger-catfight-eater-vs-down-by-the-hipster

Posted by: misterhippity on July 1, 2008 5:16 PM

Hey Jolie, answer my facebook message! :-)

Posted by: misterhippity on July 1, 2008 5:35 PM

Oh man. This is notable for JUST HOW MUCH IT LEAVE ME WANTING MORE. Why do I love blog feuds so much? Ann Althouse v. Feministing was a pretty good catfight, I must say.

Posted by: katiebakes on July 1, 2008 5:36 PM

Advertisement

Yes, that's it, suggest more. I'll make Choire go back and add them in, one by one. It's what he deserves.

Posted by: Balk on July 1, 2008 5:38 PM

Heh! But then YOU WILL HAVE TO BOLDFACE them, no?

Posted by: katiebakes on July 1, 2008 5:57 PM

Yeah, but it's not so bad when it's not all coming at you at once.

Posted by: Balk on July 1, 2008 6:16 PM

To be fair, Jen Bekman was the source of the "why don't web conferences represent women?" discussion and should be credited. Notably, Anil Dash provides a round up of men's opinions on diversity.

Posted by: Paddy Johnson on July 1, 2008 6:33 PM

THANKS!!! How valid and glorious to read. Everybody needs more Nick "Fucking" Denton in their lives, and of course the best part about Radar each month (when it arrives) is Maer Roshan's latest pic and and "wisdom" in the form a "letter" explaining the state of his worldly magazine, as well as the world at large.

All best,
Curtis "Fucking" Flowers

Posted by: worst_1_yet on July 1, 2008 9:43 PM

You're SO WELCOME!

Posted by: Balk on July 2, 2008 7:08 AM

Exemplary something-or-other.

Posted by: KarenUhOh on July 2, 2008 8:51 AM

Hippity, what message?

God I love me a good blog war. There's this crazy blogger in Boston (HI NOT ME DON'T EVEN SAY IT) who every year goes nuts on BlogHer and the women who attend. It's incredible.

Posted by: jolie on July 2, 2008 9:48 AM

Moe from Jezebel has 2 under her belt already... there was the affair de coeur with Blakeley, and now the shitstorm following her drunkass appearance with Tracie "Slut Machine" Egan on Lizz Winstead's show, which has been taking some well-deserved heat on Winstead's blog and Young Manhattanite, among others. (Everywhere EXCEPT Jezebel, of course.)

Posted by: Hez on July 7, 2008 12:47 AM