Rachel Uchitel may have once cast her spell on famous men like Tiger Woods, but the infamous mistress recently struck out with one high-profile bachelor: Jake Pavelka.

PHOTOS: Rachel Uchitel In St.Barth With Ryan Seacrest

A source revealed to RadarOnline.com exclusively that Uchitel sent one of Pavelka’s closest friends an email asking to be set up with the newly-single former pilot.